Sandwiches in Indianapolis

Explore the sandwiches menu at Taste This Fish in Indianapolis, IN, with convenient pickup options for every craving.

Popular Sandwiches to Try

2 Piece Catfish Fillet Sandwich with Pickles and Banana Peppers

$14.84

Two catfish fillets come on bread with pickles and banana peppers.

“HANDS DOWN THIS IS THE BEST FISH! We stopped here headed back to Michigan, came into town Valentine's day weekend to see Mike Epps and the crew! When I searched for fish, this place came up and when I stepped inside, I saw a photo of Mike Epps at the location! It was so fresh.... We got a small okra, 4 Catfish fillets and fries. We ate every peice of food that was in the container! We will definitely be visiting when we come back💕”

1 Piece Porkchop Sandwich

$9.25

One pork chop is served in a sandwich with wheat or white bread choices.

“Amazing southern style cuisine in the City. Everything was delicious. I highly recommend. Catfish was perfect. Pork chop sandwich was spot on. Mac & cheese was the BEST I've had in a long time. Finish with the peach cobbler. 👍🏻”

3 Piece Perch Fillet Sandwich

$13.24

Three perch fillets fill a sandwich with wheat or white bread choices.

“This fish (had the perch now twice) is soo damn good, that hot sauce is almost disrespectful! You will NOT be disappointed and don’t forget a side of those juicy and perfectly golden brown Fried Green Tomatoes!”

Made with Care at Taste This Fish

Taste This Fish in Indianapolis, IN serves a satisfying sandwiches lineup featuring a wide variety of fish and non-fish options to suit every appetite.

Standout choices include the 3 PIECE CATFISH STEAK SANDWICH, 3 PIECE WHITING FILLET SANDWICH, 2 PIECE TILAPIA FILLET SANDWICH, 3 PIECE PERCH FILLET SANDWICH, and the 1 PIECE PORK FRITTER TENDERLOIN SANDWICH.

Whether you choose dine-in, pickup, or delivery, Taste This Fish makes it easy to enjoy your favorite sandwiches right in Indianapolis, IN.

Sandwiches to Try

1 Piece Whole Catfish Sandwich

$15.54

A sandwich featuring one whole catfish fillet and available bread choices.

“Best catfish in Indiana”

1 Piece Whole Whiting Sandwich with Pickles and Banana Peppers

$12.74

A sandwich with one whole whiting fillet, pickles, and banana peppers.

“The Whiting sandwich I had last night was good. The staff was friendly. I have been looking for a good fish place in Indy. I don't have to travel two hours back to my hometown (GI) for good fish. Thank you ladies fir making me feel welcome.”

1/2 Lb Catfish Nuggets Sandwich with Pickles and Banana Peppers

$12.74

Catfish nuggets fill a sandwich with pickles and banana peppers.

“Best cat fish and Indianapolis”

2 Piece Tilapia Fillet Sandwich

$12.64

Two tilapia fillets served in a sandwich with optional bread and toppings.

“DoorDash introduced me to Taste This Fish. I have tasted the chicken wings, perch, pork chops, Tilapia, Catfish nuggets, & Swai..spaghetti, fries are all good! Cole slaw is different..not like normal, kind of sweet. Good food with good prices! I eat here all the time & have never been in person lol! I'm sure the atmosphere is cool as well as the service!”

3 Piece Whiting Fillet Sandwich

$12.74

A sandwich with three whiting fillets, pickles, and banana peppers.

“First time here.... White fish w lemon pepper, fries, coleslaw, hushpuppies, and fried corn was amazing!! Oh and the tarter sauce was the best I've ever had.”

1 Piece Pork Fritter Tenderloin Sandwich

$9.95

A sandwich featuring one pork fritter tenderloin.

2 Piece Swai Fillet Sandwich

$12.74

Two swai fillets served in a sandwich with optional bread and toppings.

“They never ever ever disappoint! Large well fried fish, extensive variety of fish. Swai is my favorite ❤️. Sides are delicious even the Mac &cheese. Onion rings flame 🔥 fires stay crispy collards with turkey yummy. Great prices! Great service and they are fast and accurate. I am a hard food critic so take my word for it you will not be disappointed. 10 outta 10.”

3 PIECE CATFISH STEAK SANDWICH

$13.24

Three catfish steak pieces fill a sandwich with wheat or white bread.

“Best fish I had in awhile. The seasoning, the crunch, the soft inside. FIE!!!”

Chicken Fillet Sandwich

$7.99

A chicken fillet forms the filling of this straightforward sandwich.

Chicken Sandwich

$8.70

A chicken sandwich with fillings and preparation unspecified.

Lunch Special Pork Fritter Sandwich & Fries From 11:00am To 2:00pm

$9.00

A pork fritter sandwich with fries is offered during lunch hours.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

2 Piece Catfish Fillet Sandwich with Pickles and Banana Peppers — This sandwich includes two catfish fillets, pickles, and banana peppers, with wheat or white bread available.
2 Piece Swai Fillet Sandwich — This sandwich contains two swai fillets, with wheat or white bread plus optional sauces, peppers, pickles, and seasoning.
1 Piece Porkchop Sandwich — This sandwich includes one pork chop, with wheat or white bread available and toppings that can be omitted.
3 Piece Perch Fillet Sandwich — This sandwich contains three perch fillets, with wheat or white bread available and optional Cajun or lemon pepper flavoring.
3 Piece Whiting Fillet Sandwich — Three whiting fillets fill a sandwich with pickles and banana peppers; wheat or white bread is available.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Indianapolis area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Yes! Taste This Fish offers kid-friendly options, including 1 Pc Swai + Fries and 2 Pc Chicken + Fries.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.